top of page
MitV Cold Case Files:
Indiana

Mervin Lehman

1969

LaGrange County

On March 22, 1969, 17-year-old Mervin Lehman was traveling with his nephew, Ernest Lehman, in a horse-drawn buggy on a rural road in LaGrange County, Indiana. As they passed another vehicle, a large rock was thrown from the car and struck Mervin. Upon the buggy’s arrival at the family home, Mervin was rushed to the hospital, where he was officially pronounced dead. Unfortunately at the time of the crime, there were no obvious suspects or leads to pursue, and the case eventually went cold. Several similar instances involving rocks being thrown at individuals in Amish buggies were reported in the area during that same time. The Indiana State Police has recently started to reinvestigate the case and believes any information from the public could be beneficial.


  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • TikTok

ALL SITE CONTENTS (C) COPYRIGHT 2026 MURDER IN THE VALLEY.COM OR AS ATTRIBUTED WITHIN THIS SITE. NO PORTION OF THIS WEBSITE MAY BE COPIED OR EMBEDDED IN OTHER PUBLICATIONS, ELECTRONIC OR OTHERWISE WITHOUT EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION OF THE SITE OWNER.

bottom of page